Skip to content

Handcrafted with Love in Wisconsin🌲

Sign Up For 35% Off & Free Shipping!!

A father and three children smiling on a porch, holding a personalized wooden "We Caught The Best Dad" sign featuring a 3D baseball glove and custom baseballs with kids' names. The banner text reads "Happy Father's Day, Personalized Baseball Signs, Handcrafted with Love in Wisconsin."
Shop Father's Day Gifts Shop Father's Day Gifts

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

Customer Favorites
Personalized "We Caught The Best Dad" wooden sign with a 3D baseball glove and custom engraved baseballs featuring kids' names. A handcrafted Father's Day gift displayed on a wooden stand.

Baseball Frames

Personalized 'Grandma's Garden' white ceramic planter pot featuring custom watercolor birth flowers for grandchildren including Sophia, Diego, and Eliana, with the sentimental inscription 'Growing since 1995'.

Planters

Personalized 'First Day of School' milestone board for kids, featuring a retro daisy flower design with custom name 'Indie', sections for date, age, and school year, and 'Things I Love' personalized details like 'Kittens & Dolls'.

Back to School

Handcrafted wooden family tree wall art with personalized 3D name hearts, custom engraved for Mother's Day and family reunions, shown in a natural wood finish with elegant script lettering.

Family Tree

ROOTED IN LOVE

Gifts That Grow With Your Family
Shop now Shop now
Shop now Shop now
Shop now Shop now

What Our Customers Have to Say!

Welcome to our new independent storefront! While this website might be new, Once Upon A Family is a long-established shop on Etsy. We have a proud history of crafting high-quality, personalized gifts and a track record of happy customers across the country. You can shop with confidence knowing you’ll receive the exact same five-star care, craftsmanship, and service here on our direct site.

Gifts For Everyone
For Mom For Dad For Kids For Pets
A person holding a large white ceramic planter containing a lush green plant. The custom planter features a "Grandma's Garden" design with two rows of vibrant watercolor birth flowers, personalized family names, and the text "growing since 1982".
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Butterfly Floral Design | Custom Family Name Gift
Sale
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Butterfly Floral Design | Custom Family Name Gift
From $22.00
From $22.00 $32.00
Framed Family Tree Sign
Framed Family Tree Sign
Framed Family Tree Sign
From $112.00
From $112.00
Round Family Tree Sign
Round Family Tree Sign
Round Family Tree Sign
$57.00
$57.00
Personalized Birth Flower Garden Stepping Stone, Unique Mother's Day Gift for Her, Gift for Grandma, Mom, Wife, Daughter, From Kids
Personalized Birth Flower Garden Stepping Stone, Unique Mother's Day Gift for Her, Gift for Grandma, Mom, Wife, Daughter, From Kids
Personalized Birth Flower Garden Stepping Stone, Unique Mother's Day Gift for Her, Gift for Grandma, Mom, Wife, Daughter, From Kids
$22.00
$22.00
Cute Christmas gift for mom, Personalized Family Tree Sign with kids, memorable keepsake idea, tree of life decor for Grandma, grandkids
Cute Christmas gift for mom, Personalized Family Tree Sign with kids, memorable keepsake idea, tree of life decor for Grandma, grandkids
Cute Christmas gift for mom, Personalized Family Tree Sign with kids, memorable keepsake idea, tree of life decor for Grandma, grandkids
$30.00
$30.00
Heart Shaped Family Tree
Heart Shaped Family Tree
Heart Shaped Family Tree
From $34.00
From $34.00
A white ceramic planter pot printed with "Granny's Bunch" and "Happy 85th Birthday" in black script. It features a double-row design of delicate watercolor birth month flowers, each with a personalized name underneath. The pot is filled with vibrant purple, yellow, and pink petunias and sits outdoors against a rustic wooden trellis.
Personalized 'Grandma's Garden' Birth Flower Planter showing a white ceramic pot with watercolor floral designs and custom names. Features a lush green plant and a badge highlighting that the design accommodates up to 24 names, making it a perfect gift for Nana or Grandma.
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Vintage Botanical | Custom Family Name Gift
From $15.00
From $15.00
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Watercolor Bouquet | Custom Family Name Gift
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Watercolor Bouquet | Custom Family Name Gift
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Watercolor Bouquet | Custom Family Name Gift
From $22.00
From $22.00

Gifts For Every Occasion
Father's Day Wedding/Anniversary Mother's Day
A personalized white building block puzzle displaying a photo of a smiling father holding his newborn baby. Below the photo is the script text "Best Dad Ever" with a small red heart. The puzzle is sitting on a light wooden nursery dresser next to a wooden ring stacker toy, a potted plant, and a stuffed bunny.
A personalized white building block puzzle resting on a wooden dock by a lake at sunset, with a fishing pole and tackle box in the background. The puzzle features a printed photo of a father and son sitting together fishing. Below the photo, custom script text reads "Reel Cool Dad" with a small red heart.
Sale
Custom Photo Brick Puzzle — Personalized Building Block Gift for Dad, Husband & Family
From $14.00
From $14.00 $18.00
Personalized Father's Day baseball desk plaque for Dad. Custom kids' name wooden sign featuring a 3D baseball glove, rustic frame, and three customized baseballs on an easel stand.
Dad and kids holding a personalized Father's Day baseball plaque. Custom wooden children's name sign featuring a 3D baseball glove, rustic frame, and customized baseballs.
Sale
Personalized Father's Day Baseball Plaque | Custom Kids Names | Dad, Papa & Grandpa Gift
From $34.70
From $34.70 $43.00
Baseball Bat Sign
Baseball Bat Sign
Baseball Bat Sign
$52.00
$52.00
Fathers day gift Home Run Baseball Sign, for dad from kids, daddy birthday, from wife, daughter, son, childrens names engraved, garage sign
Fathers day gift Home Run Baseball Sign, for dad from kids, daddy birthday, from wife, daughter, son, childrens names engraved, garage sign
Fathers day gift Home Run Baseball Sign, for dad from kids, daddy birthday, from wife, daughter, son, childrens names engraved, garage sign
$55.00
$55.00
Best Buckin Deer Sign, fathers day Gift for Dad, Husband, Son, Grandpa, Papa, From Kids, Hunting Engraved Wooden Plaque, Funny Stepdad Gift
Best Buckin Deer Sign, fathers day Gift for Dad, Husband, Son, Grandpa, Papa, From Kids, Hunting Engraved Wooden Plaque, Funny Stepdad Gift
Best Buckin Deer Sign, fathers day Gift for Dad, Husband, Son, Grandpa, Papa, From Kids, Hunting Engraved Wooden Plaque, Funny Stepdad Gift
$70.00
$70.00
Framed Family Tree Sign
Framed Family Tree Sign
Framed Family Tree Sign
From $112.00
From $112.00
Your cart
Your cart is empty
Continue shopping Continue shopping

Featured products

A person holding a large white ceramic planter containing a lush green plant. The custom planter features a "Grandma's Garden" design with two rows of vibrant watercolor birth flowers, personalized family names, and the text "growing since 1982".
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Butterfly Floral Design | Custom Family Name Gift
Sale
Personalized Birth Flower Planter | Butterfly Floral Design | Custom Family Name Gift
From $22.00
From $22.00 $32.00
Birth Flower Name Sign
Birth Flower Name Sign
Birth Flower Name Sign
From $31.00
From $31.00